Thanksgiving is nearing closer and closer, and there’s so much to plan for – even if you’re not the host! Whether you're in charge of bringing dessert to a family member's house or are just wanting a pie to enjoy at home, we've got a list of places baking the pie for you!
NOTE: Many of these locations are open for Thanksgiving orders now, so be sure to place yours before it's too late!
<div id="c3be0912bb716eee4ca644c1dfc4ecde4"></div>Where to Order Thanksgiving Pie in Tampa Bay
Boulon Brasserie
1001 Water St., Tampa, 33602
Make your Thanksgiving dessert easy with Boulon's limited-time online pie ordering. Options include Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake with Biscoff Cookie Crust, Salted Caramel Apple Pie, and Spiced Orange Dream – a toasted marshmallow fluff atop creamy Florida orange custard with a gingerbread cookie crust.
Pies are $45 each, and orders can be placed online.
Mike’s Pies
14316 Lake Magdalene Blvd, Tampa, 33618
Local to Tampa, Mike’s first opened in a small retail store in the Bay Area in ’92 to not only bring delicious pies but top-quality pies through consistency and heart!
Thanksgiving Pie options include Key Lime, Southern Pecan, and Reese's Peanut Butter Pie. Mike also sells cakes and cheesecakes as well as gluten-free options, fruit pies, and no-sugar fruit pies.
Mike's Pie is closed on Thanksgiving day, so be sure to place your order online here and pick it up before the special Thursday!
Fat Beet Farm
13830 W Hillsborough Ave., Tampa, 33635
Fat Beet Farm was started in 2020 by Jen and Tim Curci, who is also the founder of Bonefish Grill. Their farm menu boasts lots of sweet treats, including Apple Pie and a Bahama Blue Pie, featuring blueberry, pineapple, and coconut.
If pie isn't your thing, they also offer a Cookie Variety Pack, Beet Velvet Cake and a Pumpkin roll with brown butter cheesecake filling.
Oline orders are available now so be sure to place your Thanksgiving pie order soon!
Moreno Bakery
737 W. Brandon Blvd, Brandon, 33511
Moreno Bakery is a local staple serving up delicious baked goods for years. The bakery is full of Cuban history, starting with Mr. Moreno himself. When he first moved to Tampa in the 90’s he began working at Le Segunda Central Bakery in Ybor until opening up Moreno Bakery in 2008.
If you want a pie for Thanksgiving, Moreno Bakery is the place! They offer 3″, 5″, or 9″ in Apple Pie, Blueberry Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, Chocolate Cream, Pumpkin Pie, and so much more. Not to mention, his pies are super affordable!
Moreno Bakery is closed on Thanksgiving Day, so order ahead so you can pick up before the big day.
Wright’s Gourmet House
1200 S. Dale Mabry, Tampa, 33629
Wright’s is another Tampa classic serving up delicious deli items as well as yummy baked goods. Pop in for a meal or order a Thanksgiving pie! Here you can order by the slice or buy the whole pie or cake.
Pies include Pecan and Pumpkin, but they also offer plenty of cakes like Red Velvet, Strawberry, Peanut Butter Chocolate, Rum Cake, and many more! Take a bite out of history and visit Wright’s the next time you’re looking for something sweet.
Don’t forget to order your pies as soon as possible for Thanksgiving as orders tend to fill up quickly!
Alessi Bakery
2909 Cypress St., Tampa, FL 33609
Another Tampa landmark on our list! Alessi Bakery was started by Italian immigrant Nicolo Alessi, in 1912. Their bakery is filled with a delectable array of desserts such as cupcakes, cookies, cakes, pies, and pastries like eclairs, cannoli, and flan. Alessi is the perfect place to grab an assortment of flavors if you want some variety at your Thanksgiving dinner table.
Grab some of their 3″ mousse cream pies in flavors like Nutella Mousse, Boston Cream, and Fresh Fruit Bavarian, and more. They also have fresh-baked 3″ pies with traditional flavors like apple, blueberry, cherry, pecan, and pumpkin. You can also order platters of Italian Cookies, full-sized cakes, and cheesecakes (their Italian Rum Cake is a MUST TRY).
Be sure to place your order online plenty ahead of time. Delivery orders have a $120 minimum spend.
Pane Rustica
3225 S. MacDill Ave., Tampa, 33629
Pane Rustica's bakery is serving up some of its amazing pies this Thanksgiving. Order ahead to pick up one of their Pecan, Pumpkin, or Cranberry Blueberry pies, their warm Apple Tart (with or without streusel), and Pumpkin Cheesecake.
The Pie Factory
12777 Walsingham Rd., Largo, 33774
Head to Largo for some of the best pies in the area! The Pie Factory has an array of flavors perfect for Thanksgiving dessert, like Apple Berry, Apple Caramel Nut, Pecan, Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, and more. The list is almost endless!
Order a whole pie or a sampler that includes 3-4 different flavors if you can't pick just one. They also have no-sugar pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes, pastries, and specialty breads (the Orange Cranberry Nut Bread is a must-try).
Call (727) 593-1884 to place your order for Thanksgiving pie.
Zukie's Pies & Cakes
1527 Sunset Point Rd., Clearwater, 33755
Zukie began baking cakes at her family restaurant in Clearwater in 2014. Since then, she's branched off so that others can enjoy her award-winning pies year-round.
Compliment your Thanksgiving dinner with Pumpkin, Caramel Apple, Pecan, or one of their 19 other flavors! You can also choose from their cheesecakes, cakes, or gourmet cookies.
To place your pie order, call (727) 330-7938.
Is Thanksgiving pie not your thing?
If you want something beyond Thanksgiving pie, then consider these Local Bakeries for Your Thanksgiving Desserts.
Thanksgiving dinner ideas: